Generally speaking, when it comes to the parable of the talents, I find myself in agreement with biblical scholar Phyllis Tickle, who has written in regards to this parable: “Welcome to one of the most difficult and contrary passages in our entire canon. One which, on the surface at least, is fraught with unattractive paradox.” It’s not too difficult to understand why she says this. To begin with, the harsh judgment that is carried out upon the third servant seems so unlike the merciful and forgiving God that we so often proclaim. Furthermore, it’s hard to understand why the servant is punished so harshly for simply trying to keep his master’s property safe. After all, a “talent”, in Jesus day, was no meager amount of money. For the average daily worker, it was the equivalent of about 15 years worth of wages. It was the largest unit of currency imaginable, and thus for a servant, it was an incredible amount of wealth to be responsible for. Who can blame him for wanting to keep that money safe? It’s not as if he spent the money— squandering it on fine clothes and food for himself. So why is he punished so harshly?
And then finally there are those troublesome last few lines—“For all those who have, more will be given; but for those who have nothing, even what they have will be taken away.”
I would imagine that by now, most of you have heard of the Occupy protest movement which began on Wall Street several months ago and has since spread to almost every major city in the country. The protesters call themselves the 99%-- referring to the growing income disparity between the richest 1% in our country and everyone else. One sign that I have seen quite a few religious protesters carrying is one that says: Jesus is with the 99%.
That seems easy enough to understand-- after all Jesus stands with the poor, the outcast, the common man… right?
But if that is true, then what is the last line of this parable all about? It almost sounds as if Jesus is positioning himself with the 1%. It sounds an awful lot like the reality of our current economy— the rich get richer, and the poor get poorer. For those who have much, more will be given. For those who have little, even what they have will be taken away.
So what do we make of all this? How can we possibly make sense of this parable?
To answer that question, there are some who would argue that it is merely a story about how we should always be willing to share the skills and talents that God has given us. That if we don’t use those skills and talents, they might grow stale or wither away. Now I don’t necessarily disagree with that idea, but I’m not sure that message alone really gets to the heart of what Jesus is saying. Remember that a “talent” in Jesus’ day was not a reference to gifts or skills, but was in fact a ridiculously large amount of money. Jesus consciously chose to use as an example the largest unit of currency he could think of— he must have done so for a reason.
Knowing this, there are others who argue that this really is a story about money--about the responsible investment of material wealth. Indeed, this is a popular parable for annual stewardship campaigns, and it does contain a valuable message about the need to use our resources in service of the gospel, rather than simply store them up to protect them. As today is stewardship Sunday, it would be very easy for me to tell you that this parable is about taking our financial resources and investing them in the church. But I’m not going to do that, because I don’t think that tells the whole story either.
To really get at the core of what Jesus is trying to tell us here, I think it’s first helpful to look at where this parable occurs in the larger narrative. This is in fact the last parable that Jesus ever told. Jesus tells his disciples this story right before heading into Jerusalem, where he knows he will likely be arrested and condemned. He knew he would be leaving them, and he wanted to give them something that would prepare them for the journey ahead. At the heart of this message to his disciples was a deep and profound challenge. I am going away, he is telling them, but I am leaving you with the great responsibility of carrying on in my name. I am leaving you with a gift greater than any you could imagine-- good news for the poor, salvation for all people-- in other words— the gospel— and I’m entrusting you to do something with it. That is why Jesus uses the example of the “talent”—a measure of wealth that is practically unimaginable. Because the gift that he is really talking about— God’s grace and love— is also a gift that is immeasurable. And as recipients of such a gift, we are not meant to hide it away or keep it to ourselves, but to do something with it.
And so at the end of the day, this is indeed a parable about stewardship. But it’s not just stewardship of our money. It’s stewardship of the gospel itself. And I suspect that for many of us, this is actually a lot harder than simply putting money in the offering plate every Sunday. As our parable suggests, there is a certain amount of risk involved in sharing God’s greatest gift. Indeed, if it was easy and risk-free, I don’t think we would be living in the kind of world that we do-- a world where so many people are concerned more with their own security and comfort, than they are with the millions of people who live in poverty all over the world. A world where instead of sharing what we have and contributing towards abundant communities, we safeguard what belongs to us. We draw lines to delineate between what’s mine and what’s yours, what’s ours and what’s theirs. We create boundaries to say who's in, and who's out. This is a world that is desperate for a gospel of grace and hope. This is the gospel we have been given, and we are meant to share it. Indeed, we have a responsibility to share it.
Make no mistake--what Jesus is asking us to do here is not easy. And it can be scary to recognize the enormity of the gift that God has entrusted us with, and the responsibility that gift carries with it. Indeed it is fear which causes the third servant to bury his talent instead of using it. It is fear which has the potential to paralyze God’s gift within each of us-- fear that we don’t have enough, that we can’t make a difference, or that we are powerless. Fear of what other people will think of us, that we may be rejected, that we may fail. But if we draw back in fear, we lose our moral imagination for what is possible, we become timid, and we lose hope. We lose the ability to believe that God’s grace can truly transform lives. And at that point, it is we—not God-- who have consigned ourselves to the darkness.
In contrast with the fearful reactions that can hold us back, however, I want to share with you one illustration of what can happen when we are willing to put ourselves on the line in order to share God’s love and grace.
A few years ago, a group of homeless families in North Philadelphia decided to take up residence in an abandoned church. They had been living in a tent city a few blocks away, but the conditions outside had become unlivable— with rats and flooding making it especially dangerous for children. The church had been vacant for years, and so, the families moved in. Unfortunately, the denomination that owned the building was more concerned with protecting its property than caring for the homeless. As soon as they got wind of what was going on, they announced that the families had 48 hours to get out, or get arrested.
Well, a handful of Christians heard about this. They didn’t think that the church should be kicking homeless people out of a building that they weren’t even using. And so they decided to do something about it. At first it was maybe a dozen people who came to the church with sleeping bags and food. The said “we stand with you, and if they arrest you, they’ll have to arrest us to.” They took a big risk. It could have been a total failure. It could ended the next day, with the protesters getting arrested and the homeless people back out on the street. But that’s not what happened. Here is what did.
The media found out what was going on, and word slowly started to get out that a church was kicking out homeless people. People from the neighborhood came by with donations of food and blankets. College students got involved and started camping out with the families. The fire department came by with smoke detectors, and helped the families make the building safe so they wouldn’t be evicted for violating fire codes. The church, once abandoned and locked up on Sunday mornings, became alive again. Sounds of music and laughter and praise rose up out of the building. People from all walks of life worshiped side by side-- homeless people and college students, activists and businesspeople. Eventually, after many weeks of continued action, the families held a press conference. And having watched all of this unfold on the news, people were moved by compassion and wanted to help. Some people donated homes. City agencies helped others find permanent housing. People pulled together to make sure everyone was taken care of.**
This is a true story. And it’s an incredible example of how grace can multiply and transform lives, if only we are willing to risk giving it away.
And so, the question we have to ask ourselves this morning is this: is our faith life about safety and reassurance and security? Or is it about risk-taking and openness and courage? Are we willing to let the gospel loose in the world—to invest our gifts in others, to make the invisible God visible? This morning, as we celebrate Stewardship Sunday, do we see ourselves merely as stewards of an institution? Or do we see ourselves as stewards of the gospel?
As we ponder these questions, I ask you to ponder one more. God has entrusted us with unimaginable gifts— the gifts of love, grace, and indeed the gift of life itself. God has entrusted us— despite all of our imperfections, and faults, and failings— with the ministry of grace and reconciliation. God has made us partners in that work. And so it would seem that the biggest risk taker of all, is in fact God. God has given us the gifts of life and grace so that we might begin to use those gifts to create more life, to create more grace. And if God is willing to take that risk with us, well then, what is stopping us from doing the same?
**Read more about this story in "The Irresistible Revolution" by Shane Claiborn. Buy it here!